Phil. 2421: Week Three
Making It Explicit
Chapter Three
Readings:
Making It Explicit, Chapter Three: "Linguistic Practice and Discursive Commitment"
Robert Brandom, "Conceptual Content and Discursive Practice" (MSWord)
Robert Brandom, Reply to Kambartel (PDF)
Daniel Dennett, "The Evolution of `Why?'" (MSWord)
Jerry Fodor and Ernest Lepore, "Brandom Beleaguered" (PDF)
Allan Gibbard, "Thoughts, Norms, and Discursive Practice" (PDF)
Friedrich Kambartel, "Meaning, Justification, and Truth" (MSWord)
Mark Lance and Rebecca Kukla, "Perception, Language, and the First Person" (MSWord)
John MacFarlane, "Pragmatism and Inferentialism" (PDF)
Charles Taylor, "Language Not Mysterious" (MSWord)
John MacFarlane has written a computer program called GOGAR that models the game of giving and asking for reasons, i.e., the practice of discursive scorekeeping as described in Making It Explicit. As he describes it: "It is designed to help illustrate the way agents' attributions of commitments and entitlements to each other is affected by the speech acts of making, disavowing, and challenging assertions." It works on both Windows and Mac OS X. The page describing how to install and run GOGAR is here.